Whetstone Sharpening
Whetstones, also known as waterstones, are widely regarded as the best way to sharpen a knife and achieve the sharpest cutting edge. While this method requires some skill, the techniques are not too difficult to learn, and the results are often worth the effort.
The principle of whetstone sharpening is straightforward: you move the knife across the harder stone at a fixed angle, removing material from the blade to create a sharp edge.
A basic whetstone sharpening set-up consists of the following:
-
3 whetstones (coarse #200 - #400 grit, medium #1000 grit, fine #5000 - #6000 grit)
-
A stone holder (anything to keep the stone steady while sharpening)
-
Water and a clean cloth to wipe the blade
-
Your knife
Before sharpening, some whetstones need to be soaked in water. The stone must remain wet throughout the process, as the combination of water and whetstone particles creates a slurry that helps with sharpening. If the stone dries out during use, simply add more water while being careful not to wash away the slurry.
The next step is finding the right angle for sharpening. Maintaining a consistent angle is key to successful whetstone sharpening.
Once you've found and set the angle, the knife is sharpened by moving it back and forth across the stone.
Afterwards, the knife is sharpened on the stone with a back and forth motion.
There are plenty of excellent instructional videos online that walk you through the process step by step. Here are some of my top recommendations:
https://gearjunkie.com/how-to-sharpen-knife-whetstone
https://www.mediocrechef.com/blog/how-to-sharpen-kitchen-knives
The grit you use for sharpening depends on how dull your knife is, specifically how rounded the edge has become and whether any microchips need to be removed. The more material that needs to be taken off, the lower the grit you should start with. Here's a simple rule: coarser grits remove more material faster but leave a rougher surface.
The following are common grits for sharpening stones:
#200-400
for removal of material in dull edges or resetting the angle of the edge
#500-600
for sharpening of rather dull edges
#800-1500
for sharpening of slightly rounded edges when stropping / honing can't bring back the edge
#2000-4000
for edge refinement
#5000-6000
for edge polishing
#8000-20000
for mirror finished edges
Keep in mind, stones with the same grit number may not perform the same across brands—some #400 stones cut faster than a #250 from another.
You don't need a large variety of stones!
Examples of a good stone progression would be:
for polished edges:
400 / 1000 / 6000
for mirror finished edges:
400 / 1000 / 3000 / 10000
The principle of sharpening involves removing material from both sides of the blade until the rounded edge is restored to a sharp point. As you sharpen, the removal of material creates a burr along the edge, which you can feel by running your thumb from the center of the blade toward the edge.
Sharpening should continue until you can feel this burr along the entire length of the edge. Once you do, flip the blade over and sharpen the other side until the burr forms there as well. Only after this step should you move on to a finer grit to further refine the edge. As you progress to higher grits, the burr will become smaller and less pronounced.
Finally, the burr needs to be removed. This can be done by alternating swiping strokes across the stone, gradually easing up on the pressure towards the end to ensure a smooth, sharp finish.
Burr
Sharpened side
Once you're done sharpening, test the sharpness by slicing through a tomato or cutting a piece of paper.
Here a few basic tips for beginners:
-
Start slowly! Maintaining a steady angle is key. Use slower motions and lighter pressure at first. As you get more comfortable, you can increase speed and pressure.
-
Practice with a cheap knife! Slipping when the angle becomes too narrow will produce scratches on the blade. It's best to practice on less expensive, softer knives before sharpening your prized blades.
-
Don't sharpen too often! Only sharpen when stropping or honing no longer restores the edge (see "Edge Maintenance" chapter).
And some tips once you become more advanced:
-
Rotate the stone! After a while, the stones will dish. If it's double sided, rotate it to reduce the rate of dishing.
-
Regularly clean the stone with a cleaning stone! Use a cleaning stone to prevent metal particles from clogging your whetstone and reducing its cutting ability.
-
Level the stone with a flattening stone! IA dished stone makes it difficult to maintain a consistent angle. Flatten the surface with a lapping plate when needed.
-
Consider using a leather strop! Stropping on leather after sharpening on the stone will further refine and smoothen the edge, removing residues, burs and scratches and giving it an additional polish. It's done with PULLING strokes across the strop, easing up on the pressure at the end. The effect can be enhanced by applying a stropping compound on the leather as a polishing agent. A good strop can take your blade from sharp to hair-splitting sharp.
-
Consider whether you really need that high grit stone! A good leather strop can achieve a mirror finish similar to an #8000 grit stone, and it can give you comparable sharpness when properly used.
And finally a sharpening set-up for those with higher aspirations:
-
Stone holder or sink bridge
-
A minimum of 3 stones
-
Leather strop
-
Sharpening compound to load the strop
-
Cleaning stone
-
Flatterning stone